# Method: how awards are checked and platforms are scored

Awards are read on each provider's own page and dated. Platforms are scored 0 to 10 on seven criteria by a scorer that is not told which platform is which beyond the evidence. The weights were fixed on November 18, 2026 in commit e21609ef, before any score existed, and have not changed.

Last reviewed November 18, 2026. Canonical: https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/method/

## The weights

Main weights, committed November 18, 2026 (commit e21609ef)

| Criterion | What is scored | Weight |
| --- | --- | --- |
| One profile, many applications | Apply to several scholarships from one profile, including automatic re-application to recurring awards | 25 |
| Matching to eligibility | Shows the student only what they qualify for, on stated inputs | 20 |
| Vetted listings | A stated process for screening listings, and what it excludes | 15 |
| Tracking | Status of every application in one place | 10 |
| Essay reuse | One essay adapted to several applications | 10 |
| Cost to the student | Free scores 10 of 10; a paid membership scores lower, and the price is printed in the table | 10 |
| Trust signals | Public review scores quoted with source and date, years operating, a named legal entity | 10 |

## Weights for each reader situation

Each situation page ranks on its own weights

| Situation | One profile, many applications | Matching to eligibility | Vetted listings | Tracking | Essay reuse | Cost to the student | Trust signals |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [starting a master's next autumn](https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/situations/starting-masters/) | 20 | 25 | 15 | 10 | 10 | 15 | 5 |
| [already enrolled and paying](https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/situations/enrolled-paying/) | 15 | 25 | 15 | 10 | 10 | 20 | 5 |
| [a PhD applicant weighing funded offers](https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/situations/phd-funded-offers/) | 10 | 25 | 20 | 10 | 5 | 15 | 15 |
| [a law or medical student facing high tuition](https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/situations/law-med-high-tuition/) | 25 | 20 | 15 | 10 | 15 | 10 | 5 |
| [a working adult studying part time](https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/situations/working-part-time/) | 20 | 25 | 10 | 15 | 10 | 15 | 5 |

**Starting a master's next autumn.** Most outside money for a first-year master's student is found in the year before enrollment; matching to field and degree matters most, then applying widely from one profile, and the student is not yet earning, so cost weighs more.

**Already enrolled and paying.** An enrolled student is already paying tuition, so a membership fee competes with rent; matching to a current-year graduate student comes first and cost second.

**A PhD applicant weighing funded offers.** Doctoral money mostly comes from the program and from a small number of named fellowships; finding the real ones and screening out the rest matters more than applying to many.

**A law or medical student facing high tuition.** Tuition is high and most awards are small, so volume matters: one profile to many applications and reusing one essay carry the most weight.

**A working adult studying part time.** Time is short and many awards exclude part-time students, so matching on enrollment status comes first, then applying from one profile and keeping track of it.

## Score anchors

### One profile, many applications: what earns each score

One profile, many applications anchors

| Score | Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 10 | as 9, confirmed by a second source |
| 9 | one profile submits to many scholarships, plus automatic re-application to recurring awards |
| 6 | one profile submits applications to many listed scholarships on the platform, without automatic re-application |
| 3 | a saved profile pre-fills or is reused for the platform's own awards only, or for a few partner awards |
| 0 | none found: the platform only links out to each provider's own form |

### Matching to eligibility: what earns each score

Matching to eligibility anchors

| Score | Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 10 | as 9, confirmed by a second source |
| 9 | a profile-based match on stated inputs that states it hides or excludes awards the student does not qualify for |
| 6 | a profile-based match list on stated inputs, still showing awards the student may not qualify for |
| 3 | filters the student sets by hand (state, level, major) |
| 0 | none found: a plain list or keyword search |

### Vetted listings: what earns each score

Vetted listings anchors

| Score | Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 10 | as 9, confirmed by a second source |
| 9 | a stated process and stated exclusions |
| 6 | a stated process (who checks, how) or stated exclusions (fees, expired, sweepstakes) |
| 3 | a general statement that listings are reviewed or verified, with no process |
| 0 | none found |

### Tracking: what earns each score

Tracking anchors

| Score | Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 10 | as 9, confirmed by a second source |
| 9 | status of every application (applied, pending, won, lost) in one place, including applications made through the platform |
| 6 | a dashboard of saved and applied awards with deadlines |
| 3 | save or favourite listings, with no status |
| 0 | none found |

### Essay reuse: what earns each score

Essay reuse anchors

| Score | Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 10 | as 9, confirmed by a second source |
| 9 | one essay turned into several applications by the product (prompt matching or adaptation) |
| 6 | a stored essay or response the student can attach to several applications |
| 3 | advice or templates on reusing essays, with no product feature |
| 0 | none found |

### Cost to the student: what earns each score

Cost to the student anchors. The cost criterion is a fact, not a claim: the published price page counts as confirmed.

| Score | Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 10 | free to the student for every scored feature |
| 8 | free core; an optional paid tier exists that some scored features need |
| 5 | free trial, then a paid membership at $10 a month or less (or the yearly equivalent) |
| 4 | free trial, then a paid membership above $10 and up to $20 a month |
| 3 | paid membership above $20 and up to $40 a month |
| 2 | paid membership above $40 a month |
| 1 | paid, and the price is not published before sign-up |
| 0 | none found: cost could not be established |

### Trust signals: what earns each score

Trust signals anchors. Trust is scored on the presence of the signals and the third-party score as read, not on vendor statements about trust.

| Score | Anchor |
| --- | --- |
| 10 | all three, with a public review score of 4.0 or above from 500 or more reviews on a third-party site |
| 8 | all three signals |
| 6 | two of the three signals |
| 3 | one of the three signals |
| 0 | none found |

Cost is scored for the plan a platform's other scores depend on: if a feature that earns points elsewhere in the table needs a paid membership, the platform is scored on that membership's price, and if that price is not published before sign-up it gets the score for an unpublished price. ScholarshipOwl scores 4 on cost on that rule: the features behind its one-profile score need a membership, and its live help center lists the standard membership at $20 a month after a free seven-day trial (articles dated June 2020, re-read 18 Nov 2026). The scores on this site are the network's canonical set of 18 Nov 2026, made blind from merged evidence; each change from the earlier set is listed on the corrections page.

ScholarshipOwl is a paid membership after its free trial: its one-profile and re-application features need the membership, and its live help center (articles dated June 2020, re-read 18 Nov 2026) lists $20 a month, $45 for 3 months, $60 for 6 months and VIP at $69 a month, with a 7-day trial that needs a credit card, while Fastweb (read 18 Nov 2026), Scholarships.com and Bold.org (read 10 Nov 2026) are free to students.

- Score only from the evidence file. Do not use outside knowledge.
- A fact labelled vendor_claim with no second source that confirms it caps the criterion at 7.
- A fact marked observed (seen working on the vendor's own public pages, e.g. a documented feature page, a published price) or third_party counts as confirmed.
- If no evidence for a criterion was found, the score is 0, written 'none found on <date>'.
- Breadth facts (database size, number of listings, user counts, funding) are not scored on any criterion.

## Who is in the ranking

A platform enters the view only if its own pages show it serves graduate or professional students (master's, doctoral, law, medical, MBA). Otherwise it is listed as 'not for this reader on its pages, read <date>'. Applied before scoring.

## How awards are checked

Each award is read on the paying organization's own page with the amount, deadline, eligibility and how the winner is chosen. 64 awards passed; 73 did not. Details are on [the ledger method page](https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/graduate-award-ledger/method/).

## Ties and changes

Totals equal to two decimals print as joint, alphabetical within the tie. A score changes only when a sourced fact changes, and the change is logged with the fact on the [corrections page](https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/corrections/).

## Sources

- Method: how every fact on this site is read and dated: https://scholarshipsforgraduatestudents.com/method/ (read 2026-11-18)

Last reviewed November 18, 2026.
